NARRATOR: The Globe Theater, which opened in 1994, very near to its former site specializes in original productions of Shakespeare. But it wasn't until 2004 that a play was performed in the Original Pronunciation, known as OP. The play was Romeo and Juliet.
DAVID CRYSTAL: Well the globe is known for its original practices. This is why it is here, to try and recreate the theater as it was in 1600 and thereabouts. And when they started it off, they decided to do original costume, original music, with original instruments, original movement around the stage and so on.
But they never did original pronunciation, because they thought quite wrongly, but understandably, they thought nobody would understand it. But it was a very, very successful occasion, the seats were packed for that weekend, everybody loved it. And it was such a success that The Globe then decided to do a second production the following year. Production of Troilus and Cressida--
BEN CRYSTAL: It transports you back through the centuries. It's a very magical, almost hair-raising experience, especially in this space to hear that accent, a space that's sort of as close as we can get to a 400-year-old theater. And then an accent that's as close as we can get to a 400-year-old accent, with a 400-year-old play. If anything, it rounds the experience of going to see a Shakespeare play out.
DAVID CRYSTAL: Any period in the history of the English language can be studied from the point of view of how it was pronounced at the time, old English, Chaucer, and so on. In relation to Shakespeare, we're talking about the sound system or phonology, that was in use in a period called early modern English. And in a period specifically, around about the year 1600.
Now, it's a period during which pronunciation was changing very, very rapidly. So there isn't just one kind of OP. There's an OP that evolves throughout the period. For example, early on in the period, people were pronouncing the word musician as musi-see-an, musi-see-an. Later in the period, it had evolved into musi-shee-an. And of course later still, it became musician.
NARRATOR: David Crystal and his son Ben, regularly work together to demonstrate how original pronunciation differs from modern pronunciation.
BEN CRYSTAL: It's an interesting accent to tune your ear into. So we're going to run through a few pieces of Shakespeare first, in a modern sort of received pronunciation accent, the accent that you're used to hearing Shakespeare in. And then we'll switch into original pronunciation, and probably Dad will do some, and I'll do some as well, so you get to hear it in a different voice.
NARRATOR: Their first example comes from Henry V. Ben gives the modern pronunciation and David, the OP.
BEN CRYSTAL: "Oh, for a muse of fire that would ascend the brightest heaven of invention."
DAVID CRYSTAL: "Oh, for a muse of fire that would ascend the brightest heaven of inven-see-on."
BEN CRYSTAL: "A kingdom for a stage, princes to act and monarchs to behold the swelling scene."
DAVID CRYSTAL: "A kingdom for a stage, princes to act and monarchs to be-old the swelling scene."
BEN CRYSTAL: "Then, should the war-like Harry, like himself, assume the port of Mars."
DAVID CRYSTAL: "Then, should the wire like Harry, like himself, assume the port of Mars."
BEN CRYSTAL: "And that his heels leashed in like hounds, should famine, sword, and fire crouch for employment."
DAVID CRYSTAL: "And that is ails laished in like ounds, should famine, sword, and fire crouch for emplayment."
NARRATOR: How do you know that that was original pronunciation?
DAVID CRYSTAL: Well there are three kinds of evidence that you look for when you're working out the pronunciation of a stage in the history of the language. The first, and the most important piece of evidence, is the observations made by people who are writing on the language at the time. There were several people who actually commented on how words sounded, which words rhymed, and so on.
For example, how do we know that the R is pronounced at such a time. Well, Ben Jonson, the dramatist, actually tells us at one point. He says, we pronounce the R after a vowel. He actually calls it a doggy sound, grrr, or something like that. And so that kind of evidence, when you look at all the sounds, all the vowels, all the constants, you put it together and that's the first kind.
The second kind of evidence is the spellings that people use at the time. The spellings were a much better guide to pronunciation then, than spelling is today. So at one point, in Romeo and Juliet the word film is spelled P-H-I-L-O-M-E. Therefore filum, and that's a very important indication.
With the third kind of evidence, which is absolutely critical from a dramatic point of view, is that there are rhymes and puns which don't work in Modern English that do work in OP. One I remember, that we did at the Globe here, was the pun that suddenly lept out at us in the prologue to Romeo and Juliet. You do that one?
BEN CRYSTAL: Right, right. So--
"Two households, both alike in dignity, and fair Verona where we lay our sin from ancient grudge break to new mutiny, for civil blood makes civil hands unclean. From forth the fatal loins of these two foes, a pair of star-crossed lovers take their life, who's mis-adventured piteous overthrows doth with their death, bury their parents' strife."
And it's not-- It's the lines isn't it?
DAVID CRYSTAL: It's the lines. "From forth the fatal lines"-- now the thing is, loins was pronounced lines, and the word lines, was pronounced lines.
BEN CRYSTAL: So there's a double meaning, there.
DAVID CRYSTAL: So there is a pun, yeah, a pun on loins and lines. Genealogical lines on the one hand and physical loins, on the other. Which is completely missed If you do it in modern English. It's a good example.
NARRATOR: David and Ben have also discovered that nearly two-thirds of Shakespeare's sonnets have rhymes that don't work in Modern English, that do work in OP.
DAVID CRYSTAL: Give us a good one. 1-1-6?
BEN CRYSTAL: I think 1-1-6 is it's interesting, because lots of people have it at their weddings and they think of it as being a very sort of highfalutin sonnet.
"Let me not the marriage of true minds admit impediments."
But it completely changes in OP, particularly because of the rhymes.
"Love is not time's fool, the rosy leps and checks within his been-in sickles compass come. Love alters not, with his oars and wakes. But bears it out een to the edge u-dum. If this be error and upon me proft, I never writ, nor no man ever loved."
DAVID CRYSTAL: Yeah, pruved and loved, I mean it's lovely isn't it. Proved and loved, it simply doesn't work.
BEN CRYSTAL: It completely falters. "If this be error and upon me proved, I never writ, nor no man ever loved."
DAVID CRYSTAL: That's right.
BEN CRYSTAL: It doesn't quite work.
NARRATOR: When Romeo and Juliet was performed at The Globe, David and Ben were advisors on the production.
DAVID CRYSTAL: One of the most interesting things was the way in which the actors all said that the OP altered their performance, quite fundamentally. You have to remember, the play was being done in two versions that year. There was a modern English version, and an OP version as well. The actors had to learn the thing twice. And it just changed the way they perceived their characters, didn't it Ben?
BEN CRYSTAL: It did, well I mean, it's a lot faster, the accent. With modern Shakespeare, it's often very reverential in the way that we pronounce it. You know it's "assume the port of Mars--" it's much faster in OP, it's "assume the port of Mars". The OP Romeo and Juliet was 10 minutes faster.
And it does something else to you as well, to me, it drops my voice. I use my bottom register a lot more. You know, "assume the port of Mars", it makes me sort of hunker down, doesn't sort of seem so cut off from the neck, you know, from [? yules of ?] fire, it connects with the body a bit more, for some reason. It's an earthier accent.
NARRATOR: The experience of Romeo and Juliet, also demonstrated that far from making Shakespeare more difficult to understand, it can actually make the original meaning clearer, as can be seen in this extract from, As You Like It.
BEN CRYSTAL: "And so from hour to hour we ripe and ripe. And then from hour to hour we rot and rot. And thereby hangs a tale."
It's a really, really rude sex joke. He's talking about prostitutes and you know, the King's evil and all that kind of thing. It's completely missed when you do it in a modern accent. The last time I saw As You Like It, the actor came to the front and said, "from hour to hour we ripe and ripe and from hour to hour we rot and rot and thereby hangs a tale." Anyway, the gag is completely missed.
DAVID CRYSTAL: What we see is a joke working that doesn't work in Modern English. And it's all based on one very simple sound shift. The pronunciation of whore as oar, you'll notice two things about it, the H drops at the beginning, H often dropped in early modern English in that way.
And you get this other change, hour in modern English, becoming oar, in the earlier version. And the combination of the two changes together, produces a coming together of the two words. And therefore, a perfect pun.
BEN CRYSTAL: There's something about working our way back to Shakespeare, rather than dragging him into the 21st century-- When you're standing on The Globe stage, they would light the theater as if it's daylight, because Shakespeare's plays would have been performed about 2:00 in the afternoon, and that means that you can make direct eye contact with every single member of the audience.
And then suddenly Shakespeare, going see a Shakespeare play becomes a two-way dynamic, a complicity. It means that, as an actor, as Hamlet, I can come out and ask you, "what should I do?" Should I kill Claudius? I don't know what to do. Everything's really confusing. Help me. That's what Shakespeare's monologues were about.
So if you can sort of imagine that there's that extra dimension when you're working in a space like this, you get a similar sort of extra dimension when you use Shakespeare's accent.